Take your health into your own hands

Take your health into your own hands

Take your health into your own hands

Omega-3: some doubt about the benefits

66_omega3

Celebrated for about two decades as an extraordinary means of preventing cardiovascular disease (to the point of being prescribed as a true prophylactic therapy after a heart attack) and as a potential defense against several types of cancer, in recent months the role of the omega-3 is seeing substantial retrenchment on both fronts.

After the results of the study ASCEND (A Study of Cardiovascular Events in Diabetes.) published during 2018, had questioned the real utility of these essential fatty acids as protection against acute cardiovascular events in people with diabetes, the findings of the double-blind randomized controlled trial VITAL (Vitamin D Omega-3 Trial), recently published in the New England Journal of Medicine, deal a further blow to their use for preventive purposes in the general population, which lacks specific risk factors.

Contrary to past inferences from observational studies, which seemed to indicate a lower incidence of cardiovascular disease and cancer among people who consumed larger amounts of fatty fish from the North Seas (salmon, mackerel, tuna, herring, sardines, etc.) known to be rich in omega-3, fish oil or targeted supplements, the results of the VITAL study showed no difference in incidence for either group of diseases between those taking omega-3 (at a dosage of 1 mg/day) and vitamin D3 (at a dosage of 2,000 IU/day) and those taking preparations similar in appearance but completely inert biologically (placebo).

Even deepening the analysis and focusing on individual aspects, supplementation with omega-3 and vitamin D3 resulted in effects entirely superimposed on placebo, with comparable rates of overall cardiovascular events, stroke, death from cardiovascular causes, death from oncological causes, and death from all causes. The only favorable data concerned myocardial infarction rates, which were slightly lower among those taking omega-3, and side effects, which were similar for omega-3 and placebo (indicative of the harmlessness and good tolerability of supplementation, but not sufficient to justify its use).

But how is it possible that what seemed useful until yesterday is no longer useful today? As mentioned, until now, the benefits associated with omega-3 supplementation for primary prevention had been highlighted mainly in observational studies, that is, comparing the incidence of cardiovascular disease and cancer in populations that were or were not taking these essential fatty acids for various reasons, but without prior patient selection criteria or standardization of administration for timing, mode and dosage.

Studies of this kind can provide insights into the potential effects of a substance or drug in the body, which must, however, be confirmed in the context of double-blind randomized controlled trials, in which two groups of patients with overlapping characteristics and exposed to comparable conditions are randomly assigned to take either the active treatment or the inactive placebo and monitored for a predefined period of time. Only such studies, such as the VITAL study, can provide reliable information about the effects of a drug or other preventive or therapeutic intervention.

The outcomes of the VITAL study deserve special attention because they were obtained on a very large population (nearly 26 thousand people) and of different ethnicities (although all of them are residents of the United States), being, therefore, decidedly robust.

On the other hand, the new data are not inconsistent with those obtained in the late 1990s as part of the GISSI – Prevention study, conducted by the Italian Group for the Study of Survival in Myocardial Infarction. This “landmark” trial had, in fact, clearly demonstrated the preventive benefits of omega-3 supplementation in patients who had already had a first heart attack and were, therefore, at increased risk of experiencing a second one (secondary prevention).

Source

  • Manson JE et al. Marine n-3 Fatty Acids and Prevention of Cardiovascular Disease and Cancer. N Engl J Med 2019;380:23-32
  • Keaney JF, Rosen CJ. VITAL Signs for Dietary Supplementation to Prevent Cancer and Heart Disease. N Engl J Med 2019;380:91-92
  • Italian Group for the Study of Survival in Myocardial Infarction. Dietary supplementation with n-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids and vitamin E after myocardial infarction: results of the GISSI-Prevenzione trial. Lancet 1999;354(9177):447-55.

FEATURED SPECIALISTS

  • Profile picture of Dr. Vittorio Margutti
    active 4 years, 7 months ago

    Orthopedists, Basic Doctors

    • Via Marco Simone Poli 1 - Guidonia Montecelio
    phone
  • Profile picture of Dr. Roberto Zaffaroni
    active 4 years, 7 months ago

    Basic Doctors, Therapist

    • Via San Francesco D' Assisi 5 - Varese
    phone
  • Profile picture of Dott. Flavio Della Croce
    active 4 years, 7 months ago

    Psychotherapists, Basic Doctors

    • Via Sacconi 1 - Borgonovo Val Tidone
    phone
  • Profile picture of Dott.ssa Emanuela Costantino
    active 4 years, 7 months ago

    • Via Gallinara 2/B - Cagliari
    phone
  • Profile picture of Dott.ssa Irene Pistis
    active 4 years, 7 months ago

    Aesthetic Doctors, Basic Doctors, Certifying Doctor

    • Via della Reoubblica 461/3 - Vergato
    phone

RELATED ARTICLES

Antacid drugs: could promote allergies

A few weeks ago, some antacid drugs used to Relieve heartburn, dyspepsia and/or gastroesophageal reflux disease have raised some alarm over the presence of impurities in some batches, Promptly withdrawn

How to protect the health of the kidney

The two kidneys process everything we eat or drink, including medications, supplements, and anything that can harm us. THE 10 RULES Prevention is the only effective solution to prevent kidney

Methods of poisoning: antidepressant drugs

Today patients with antidepressant drug overdose. represent a large portion. The pharmacological properties of the antidepressants are multiple and include interference with release of adrenaline at the level of brain

Vaccines, it is alarm throughout Italy

The situation in Italy regarding the vaccines: almost in all regions there is less than 95 percent coverage, a threshold that does not guarantee herd immunity. The past few days

RELATED PATHOLOGIES

Diseases of the heart valves

Heart valve diseases comprise a large group of structural alterations and dysfunctions, congenital or more often acquired, that prevent the valves that separate the different chambers of the heart (atria

Heart failure

Heart failure corresponds to a condition in which the heart is unable to receive and/or pump blood with sufficient force to the lungs and the rest of the body, due

Carotid stenosis

Carotid artery stenosis corresponds to a narrowing of the caliber of the carotid arteries, which are the main blood vessels supplying the brain with oxygen- and nutrient-rich blood (particularly glucose),

Heart failure (acute)

Acute Heart Failure (AHF) is a potentially life-threatening clinical condition that can result from the worsening of an already diagnosed chronic heart failure (heart failure) or represent its onset event.

Intracranial hypertension

Increased pressure within the head box may be related to cerebral edema or the presence of an intracranial expansive lesion, an obstruction of CSF circulation, or the association of these

Obstructive sleep apnea

Repetitive episodes of upper airway obstruction may occur during sleep, often accompanied by reduced oxygen saturation. Such episodes are accompanied in almost all cases by snoring. Apneas often end with

Atherosclerosis

Atherosclerosis is a pathological process that leads to the progressive formation of localized deposits composed mainly of fat and cholesterol and platelets (atheromas or atherosclerotic plaques) within the walls of

Cardiac Echodoppler

The echocardiogram, also known as echocardiography, is a diagnostic imaging technique based on the use of ultrasound, which is quick and easy to perform, harmless, painless, and low-cost, and because

Deep vein thrombosis (DVT)

Deep vein thrombosis (DVT) occurs when a clot (thrombus) forms within a vein and completely or partially occludes it, blocking or restricting blood flow in that vessel. In principle, any

Myocardial infarction

Acute myocardial infarction, which affects about 100,000 people in Italy each year, corresponds to the death of a part of the heart muscle due to an interruption in the supply

FEATURED SPECIALISTS

  • Profile picture of Dr. Roberto Zaffaroni
    active 4 years, 7 months ago

    Basic Doctors, Therapist

    • Via San Francesco D' Assisi 5 - Varese
    phone
  • Profile picture of Dott. Giovanni Adamo
    active 4 years, 7 months ago

    Angiologists, Basic Doctors

    • Provincia di Ragusa - Ragusa
    phone
  • Profile picture of Dott.ssa Monica Calcagni
    active 4 years, 7 months ago

    Gynecologists, Aesthetic Doctors, Basic Doctors

    • Via Casilina 32 - Arce
    phone
  • Profile picture of Dott.ssa Irene Pistis
    active 4 years, 7 months ago

    Aesthetic Doctors, Basic Doctors, Certifying Doctor

    • Via della Reoubblica 461/3 - Vergato
    phone
  • Profile picture of Dott.ssa Floriana Di Martino
    active 4 years, 7 months ago

    Aesthetic Doctors, Basic Doctors

    • Piazza della Rinascita 13 - Pescara
    phone
NUTRITION AND DIET
 
NATURE, SPORTS, PLACES
 
CULTIVATING HEALTH
 
MENOPAUSE
 
MOM IN SHAPE
 
TRADITIONAL CHINESE MEDICINE
 
HEART SURGERY
 
MEDICINES AND MEDICAL DEVICES
 
PARENTING
 
THE CULTURE OF HEALTH
 
HEALTH UTILITIES
 
GENERAL MEDICINE
 
NATURAL MEDICINE, THERMAL
 
MIND AND BRAIN
 
NEUROVEGETATIVE DYSTONIA
 
WAYS OF BEING
 
HEALTH AND SOCIETY
 
HEALTHCARE AND PATIENTS
 
SEXUALITY
 
OLDER AGE
 
CANCERS
 
EMERGENCIES
 
NUTRITION AND DIET
 
NATURE, SPORTS, PLACES
 
CULTIVATING HEALTH
 
MENOPAUSE
 
MOM IN SHAPE
 
TRADITIONAL CHINESE MEDICINE
 
HEART SURGERY
 
MEDICINES AND MEDICAL DEVICES
 
PARENTING
 
THE CULTURE OF HEALTH
 
HEALTH UTILITIES
 
GENERAL MEDICINE
 
NATURAL MEDICINE, THERMAL
 
MIND AND BRAIN
 
NEUROVEGETATIVE DYSTONIA
 
WAYS OF BEING
 
HEALTH AND SOCIETY
 
HEALTHCARE AND PATIENTS
 
SEXUALITY
 
OLDER AGE
 
CANCERS
 
EMERGENCIES
 
DIGESTIVE SYSTEM
 
RESPIRATORY SYSTEM
 
UROGENITAL SYSTEM
 
HEART AND CIRCULATION
 
SKIN
 
INFECTIOUS DISEASES
 
EYES
 
EARS, NOSE, AND THROAT
 
BONES AND LIGAMENTS
 
ENDOCRINE SYSTEM
 
NERVOUS SYSTEM
 
DIGESTIVE SYSTEM
 
RESPIRATORY SYSTEM
 
UROGENITAL SYSTEM
 
HEART AND CIRCULATION
 
SKIN
 
INFECTIOUS DISEASES
 
EYES
 
EARS, NOSE, AND THROAT
 
BONES AND LIGAMENTS
 
ENDOCRINE SYSTEM
 
NERVOUS SYSTEM
 

your advertising
exclusively ON
MY SPECIAL DOCTOR

complete the form and you will be contacted by one of our managers